Reverse Psychology: Expecting the Unexpected



Listeners are able to learn to expect the unexpected.

  • Schoenberg's system of composing with 12 tones. Schoenberg (correctly) claimed that undue emphasis on a pitch would raise it to the status of a tonic.

  • 12-tone composition: a system for avoiding a tonal hierarchy

  • 12-tone rows exhibit near optimum contra-tonal structure (Huron & von Hippel)

    E.g. Schoenberg's Opus 27, No. 3:

    Initial Row Possible Continuation Maximum Key Correlation
    G, F#, D, E C +0.64
    G, F#, D, E C# +0.50
    G, F#, D, E D# +0.47
    G, F#, D, E F +0.43
    G, F#, D, E G# +0.46
    G, F#, D, E A +0.81
    G, F#, D, E A# +0.55
    G, F#, D, E B +0.79